Library @kv2 Calicut

Education And Dedication

Article of the week:In pursuit of socially mixed schools

In pursuit of socially mixed schools

    Manabi Majumda Jos Mooij

The interaction between less privileged and rich students will enrich the experience of both.

The Supreme Court recently upheld the validity of Clause 12 of the Right to Education Act that mandates aided and non-aided private schools to reserve 25 per cent of the seats for disadvantaged children in their neighbourhoods. This is arguably a landmark judgement that creates an opportunity, though not a certainty, for rendering school a site of social transformation.

In his novel Maid Marian, T.L. Peacock poses a series of questions and answers: “Why are laws made? For the profit of somebody. For whom? Of him who makes them first and of others as it may happen.” Will this court-validated law affect the educational fortunes of ordinary people only superficially, incidentally and occasionally, as the quote suggests, or will it present a real possibility for building up inclusive and socially mixed schools? At a time when one notices a yawning social distance between the students of government schools and those of private schools (especially the elitist ones), will the mandate for recasting the social composition of school somewhat disturb, if not dismantle, the roots of background social inequalities within which the education system is embedded?

Real possibility

While there is no guarantee for inevitable progress, there is a real possibility here. We try to substantiate this claim by invoking a series of binaries that are germane to an analysis of the current school education system in India, namely, “elite capture” versus “elite flight”, “mirror” versus “window”, mind versus hand, and choice versus voice.

There was a time when government schools were peopled almost entirely with children from upper and middle classes. Those were the days of elite capture of government-run elementary schools. But as doors of these schools started opening up for the masses, the elite, in pursuit of exclusivity, voted with their feet in favour of private schools — a phenomenon we describe as elite flight. Now government schools are peopled mostly with children from less privileged sections of society.

It is indeed ironical that the government school system that is technically universal and meant to cater to all is rendered targeted. It is not that the government-run schools target any particular socio-economic group or exclude others; it is the elite that discount these schools and select themselves out in favour of private schools. By the dint of their exit the government school system is rendered, for all practical purposes, a ‘BPL’ programme. The elite’s flight away from integration solidifies the divide between haves and have-littles.

For example, a full page advertisement in Outlook magazine by an upmarket school “…warns parents that their maid servant might become their child’s guru if they do not send the child to a high fee paying private school”, openly and unabashedly declaring the desirability of a social divide in the education system (Rohit Dhankar, 2010). Educational inequality is not only not seen as a problem, it is even considered desirable. It is against the backdrop of this barefaced avowal of the idea and practice of school segregation that we need to assess the meaning and significance of the Supreme Court ruling that ratifies a measure intended to promote social integration of children and to curb persistent leanings towards an “education apartheid”.

Inclusive education

An argument for inclusive education of course raises the next obvious question: inclusion into what? According to the American educationist Emily Style, education “needs to enable the student to look through window frames in order to see the realities of others and into mirrors in order to see her/his own reality reflected”. One may wonder what kind of mirror or window the country’s school education is in reality, and for whom. Schools often are a mirror for the children of the elite and middle classes, who see the dominant worldview reflected in the curriculum and school processes, while it is a window frame for students of subordinate groups who get a peep into the world of the dominant society.

It is a real concern therefore how to make private schools, and their textbooks, classroom pedagogy and school practices sufficiently inclusive of diversities that define Indian society, and consequently to ensure that genuinely socially mixed schools can become a reality.

‘Solution,’ not ‘problem’

In dealing with such vexing issues, poorer children are often seen as part of the “problem” vis-à-vis their more affluent and “able” peers; the focus is largely on how their lack of background training may slow down the process of teaching-learning in the classroom that would be costly for the other privileged children. But there is much neglect of the thought that the presence of less privileged children in school and their active participation in classroom and other school processes could actually be part of the “solution” toward enriching the currently “provincial” and isolated school-life of many a rich kid, trapped within the narrow confines of five-star schools.

There is a conspicuous silence about what cultural riches disadvantaged children could bring into the classroom to the profit of their peers, about how their background knowledge, skills and experiences could strike at the root of the separation between mind and hand, between mental and manual labour that sadly shapes much of India’s mainstream educational practice. A school with children from different social and occupational groups could provide an antidote to a still-strong aversion to manual labour among the upper and middle classes, and a belief in the inferiority of manual occupations.

It is certainly important, and even genuinely challenging, to ensure that have-little children feel comfortable to mix and study with their have-enough classmates and vice versa and to see to it that new zones of exclusion do not come up within the school premises. But such foreboding need not detract from the truth that academic and social abilities are randomly distributed among children from different social strata; the expressed anxiety that the quality of education will suffer upon the entry of poor children into private classrooms presumes a non-random, class-specific distribution of abilities among children, which when apparent is actually an upshot of social exclusionary forces.

‘Overzealous’ and ‘unduly’

It would, therefore, not stand to reason if the issue of “quota” in private schools is couched in terms of a trade off between parental choice for educational quality and the “overzealous” and “unduly” imposing public voice in favour of educational equity. Why should choice and quality be seen as automatically interlocked, but quality and equity as oppositional? Doesn’t the choice talk sometimes mask, in the name of quality, a penchant for exclusivity, a preference away from integration? The remarks of the principal of Shri Ram (a much sought after school in Delhi and one among others that challenged the Education Act in the Supreme Court) vis-à-vis “a quota for underprivileged kids” that the school adopted under a Delhi law smack of such an attitude. When the principal’s household help enrolled her son at Shri Ram, “I [the principal] was shocked. A parent in my school, mopping my floors! I just couldn’t handle it. I can’t sit across the table from someone who sweeps my floors” (Wall Street Journal, 2011).

When background social inequalities keep breaking into the school system with such force, what are the ways in which a measure to promote greater social integration of school children can bear fruit? Here looms large the centrality of ‘voice’ — a clear articulation and open exchange of people’s educational aspirations, ideas, demands and complaints — in exploring how the purpose as well as quality of education be wedded to the idea of justice.

There are several trouble spots in Indian schools, both public and private, such as curriculum overload, excessive examination-orientation, competition for marks, etc., that can be dealt with only through public discussion, effort and action, and not through individualised private choice. A socially mixed school, with its contact and coupling with many lives, experiences, and viewpoints, is likely to facilitate such a collective endeavour.

(Manabi Majumdar is at Centre for Studies in Social Sciences, Calcutta, and Jos Mooij at the International Institute of Social Studies, Erasmus University, Rotterdam. They are the co-authors of Education and Inequality in India: A Classroom View, Routledge, 2011.)

Courtesy:THE HINDU ,MAY 5, 2012 OPED

Filed under: Selected Articles, , ,

May 2020
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Library Pages

BOOK FAIR

Dear Parent, Kendriya Vidyalaya No:2 is organizing Scholastic book fair in the School on 3rd, 4th and 5th August 2015 with a vision of “Putting a Book in every child’s hand. You are cordially invited to participate in the event whole heartedly. We believe that every student should be encouraged to become a lifelong reader.. Looking forward to your whole-hearted support. Venue: Library (1st floor) Timing: 8:30-3:00

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Twitter Updates

LIBRARY ON YOUTUBE

UBI ONLINE FEE COLLECTION

UBI ONLINE FEE COLLECTION

READER OF THE MONTH JUNE 2019

Book Exhibition Inauguration-2018

NIE Programme

Teachers Day 2017-Student Librarian

BOOK FAIR 2017

Book exhibition

Dr.K.Sreekumar along with readers' club members

BOOK TALK

Reader of the month July2017

Readers club programme

Shri:Mahipal Singh ,Principal

Work shop on newspaper in education :AUGUST2016

NIE workshop for primary section August 2016

BOOK FAIR

Scholastic Book fair August:2015

RSS Unknown Feed

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

Article Alert

1. R.Prasannan :Unfolding the Harappan mystery ,Page.58-60.The Week Vol.33. No.18 ,April.29,2012 2. VENKATESAN.V :Mission Impossible :Experts agree that the economic and environmental costs of interlinking India's rivers far outweigh its projected benefits., Frontline ,Volume 29 - Issue 07 :: Apr. 07-20, 2012

Magazine Alert

Magazine alert

Magazine Alert

MAGAZINE Alert

Terra Green

Magazine Alert

Magazine Alert

Down To Earth

Magazine Alert

Magazine Alert

Magazine Alert

Magazine Alert

Magazine Alert

RSS Competition Alerts

  • INTERNATIONAL CREATIVITY COMPETITION 2020
    Graduate Studies and International Class of Telkom University presents International Creativity Competition (ICC) 2020 for you, during the stay-at-home period, and total prizes would be shared among various competition categories: Video Competition, Visual Story Telling, News Casting and Short Story Writing. Diploma and Bachelor degree from any majors are ab […]
  • All India Online Cyberspace Quiz Competition
    CYBERTALKINDIA is an ISO Certified Firm established in the year 2018 focus on cyber-security training and skill development about digital citizenship and internet safety. With the cashless economy boom, there is a pressing need to create a cyber-aware generation. We have experience of training School Kids, College Students, Professionals, Law Enforcement Age […]
  • 22nd International Child Art Exhibition 2020
    Organised by Kshitij a society is formed to promote art by organizing exhibitions of paintings, greeting cards, cartoon at national & international level. Art has the power to depict our consciousness and this in turn should depict our love and concern for “NATURE”, which is this year’s big theme across the globe. Entries must be on the theme/subject Pra […]
  • 2020 APL Problem Solving Competition
    Dyalog Ltd invites you to use the APL programming language and your problem solving skills to compete for a total of USD 6,500 in cash prizes and a paid trip to the next Dyalog user meeting. For details of the contest, please click on the link above and visit Scholastic World blog
  • International Short Story Contest- Kidsworldfun
    Kidsworldfun.com invites entries to their International Short Story Contest 2020. Eligibility Contest is open to students of 7 to 16 years all over the world For details of the contest, please click on the link above and visit Scholastic World blog
  • H First International English Olympiad 2020
    The 'International English Olympiad (IEO)' by 'H First' is an attempt to not only locate the best talent in the world when it comes to the English language, it is supposed to be a measuring stick for students to assess where they stand in comparison to other students around the world to give themselves, their parents, and their teachers a […]

New Arrivals