Library @kv2 Calicut

Education And Dedication

Article of the week:Universities, ours and theirs

There are four critical differences between universities of the western world and ours. Thefirst is that they do all they can, when they recruit young faculty, to make way for excellence. We do everything to block its entry. We start discouraging talent early, but a few bright youngsters manage to come up despite our best efforts. They are the ones who face the greatest resistance from our institutions at the time of selection for vacancies. The norms and standards that western institutions apply for selecting young faculty focus on individualised assessment of potential. Senior people and administrators who make decisions make sure that the aspirants are assessed on the basis of what they have published, the quality of research they have done, and how passionate they seem about the pursuit of knowledge and teaching.

Mechanical criteria

In our case, the initial criteria applied are purely mechanical. Any hint of trans-disciplinary interest means that the candidate loses the chance to be interviewed. And those who somehow escape this fate are ultimately sized up at the time of interview in terms of the lobbies they might belong to. Someone rare enough to be independent of personal as well as intellectual lobbies is the first to be eliminated. In the semi-final act of short listing, those lacking support from the dominant lobbies get weeded out. Then, in the ultimate moment, hard bargaining takes place and the institution’s future gets sealed. If there is someone with an unusual background or achievement, you can depend on the selection committee to find a technical ground to reject him or her. The only way he or she might get appointed is if a determined Vice-Chancellor forces the person in. Democratic procedures and correctness have become incompatible with respect for quality. Our universities feel comfortable with the labyrinth of eligibility norms that the University Grants Commission has nurtured with relentless energy to issue circulars over the decades. Selection committees debate over the finest of technicalities to justify the selection of the average, allowing anyone with sheen to get stuck and lost in the maze of criteria.

The second major difference between our universities and the western ones relates to the concept of teaching. We calculate teaching in terms of periods taken. The Radhakrishnan Commission had bemoaned the fact that our colleges work like higher secondary schools. More than six decades after the commission gave its report, life in our undergraduate colleges is just the same. The UGC demands 18 periods of teaching per week from an assistant professor. “Isn’t that reasonable?,” one might ask. Of course, it is, if you ignore what the word “teaching” means. The practice of calculating teachers’ daily work by counting the number of periods they stand beside the blackboard exposes the hollowness of our system and the concept of education. It also shows how little we have progressed since colonial days when accountability was tied to crude measures. How far Britain has moved away from the procedures it introduced in India long ago became apparent to me a year ago when I was invited to serve on a course evaluation committee in a British institute. After examining the course content, the recommended readings and the description of each lecture session taken through the year, the committee met groups of students from the previous three years. We also read the detailed feedback each student is required to give at the end of each course.

Our discussion with students and — separately — with their teachers was frank and detailed. We learnt how students assessed their teachers in terms of preparedness for each class, personal interest in the subject, the pedagogic strategies used to arouse interest, and not just regularity — which was, in fact, taken for granted. In India, we worry about attendance records to keep the student under pressure to attend classes that may be altogether devoid of intellectual stimulation. Despite attendance norms being stringent, there are classes without much attendance. There are also numerous cases of attendance without classes. An obsolete system of examination helps teachers who miss classes and make no effort to relate to students. There are many who take the number of periods required, but their classes have no soul or spark.

Concept of knowledge

The third critical difference between life in an Indian university and a university in the West arises out of the concept of knowledge embedded in the system. The crude measures our regulatory bodies such as the UGC apply in the name of accountability mask the epistemic sterility of the curriculum, the pedagogic process and examination. In the West, curriculum and pedagogy both follow the teacher’s own research interests. Even smaller universities with limited resources attempt to cultivate a research environment. Topics of research reflect the university’s concern for the social and natural world surrounding it. Research is seen as an inquiry to solve problems as well as to induct the young into a community of inquires. Keeping a record of hours spent on direct teaching becomes irrelevant in such a system, even in the case of undergraduate students. To keep their research interests alive and popular, senior professors engage with young undergraduates who bring fresh questions and perspectives to ongoing inquiries. In India, you stop teaching undergraduate classes as soon as you attain professorial status. Teaching and research are seen as two separate activities. While teaching is perceived as institutional work, research is viewed as a personal agenda for moving forward in one’s career. Not surprisingly, infrastructure and administrative procedures that might facilitate research do not exist. Obstacles do, and the teacher who makes the mistake of initiating a research project has to struggle all the way to its completion and the ritual of report submission to the funding agency. No one among colleagues or in the administration cares to know the findings, let alone their implications. Teaching goes on following the grooves of preset syllabi, like the needle boring into an old gramophone record.

The fourth critical difference lies in the library. In the West, even in the most ordinary universities, the library forms the centre of life, both for teachers and students. Librarians enjoy a high status as their contribution to academic life cuts across academic disciplines. They work closely with teachers and students in the various tasks involved in procurement of books and journals, keeping the library quiet and friendly, and ensuring speedy access. Our case is the opposite. The library exists on the margins of the classroom. In many universities, undergraduate students are not allowed to use the university library. Subscription to journals and magazines has dwindled over the years, and maintenance of past volumes is now seen as an obsolete practice because e-storage is available. We forget that the library is not merely a service; it is also a physical space whose ethos induces the young to learn the meaning of belonging to a community of scholars. Our reading rooms carry an unkempt, hapless look, with clanking ceiling fans and dog-eared books waiting to be removed. Book acquisition has been saturated with petty corruption and a crowd of spurious publishers has thrived on the outskirts of the academia.

Symptomatic

These four critical differences are, of course, symptomatic of deeper problems entrenched in structures that govern higher education in India. Those who perceive all problems in financial terms miss the barren landscape of our campuses. Inadequacy of funds is, of course, worrisome, but it cannot explain the extent to which malice, jealousy and cussedness define the fabric of academic life in our country. There is a vast chasm that separates the Indian academia from society. Let alone the masses, even the urban middle class cares little for what goes on inside classrooms and laboratories.

The citizenry does not see higher education as an intellectual resource. Nor do political leaders. The only commonly understood purpose that the system of higher education serves is to alleviate — and keep under tolerable levels of discomfort — what the British economist, Ronald Dore, has called the ‘Diploma Disease’ in his 1976 classic on education in developing economies. Dore has explained why a country like ours will continue to lag behind the West in knowledge and technique so long as we keep using mark-sheets and certificates to screen the young for further education and employment. His insight that the valid goal of widening the pool of talent is defeated by bureaucratisation of selection continues to be pertinent across the colonised world.

(The writer is Professor of Education at Delhi University and a former Director of NCERT.)

 

Cortesy:http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-opinion/article3744274.ece

Filed under: Article of the week, ,

August 2012
M T W T F S S
« Jul   Sep »
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Library Pages

Tag

2014 Admission Notification rie aiish admission cbse CBSE heritage India Quiz CBSE heritage India Quiz sample papers CBSE OTBA cbse otba class ix CIPET Class IX Class X Common Law Admission Test green olympiad IISER ADMISSION IMU Indian Maritime University IPM IIM INDORE ix Ix Mathematics sample papers ix Ix Science sample papers Ix Maths sa1 papers Ix Science sa1 papers Ix Science sample s1 papers Junior mathematics olympiad KENDRIYA VIDYALAYA NO2 CALICUT Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan Kishore Vaigyanik Protsahan Yojana question paper KV2CALICUT kvpy kvpy question paper KVS kvs green olympiad KVS Junior Mathematics Olympiad KVS RO Ernakulam KVS Study material Mathematics olympiad Mathematics Sample Papers Maths Maths Olympiad 2012 model papers nata National Aptitude Test in Architecture (NATA) NATIONAL DEFENCE ACADEMY NATIONAL ENTRANCE SCREENING TEST(NEST): National Talent Search National Talent Search examination NDA nest NIFTEM nios ntse ntse examination ntse question paper ntse Sample Paper Biology ntse sample questions Open Text-based Assessment Open Text-based Assessment CLASS XI OTBA otba biology class xi Problem Solving Assessment PSA QUESTION CLASS 9 PSA QUESTION PAPER CLASS IX Question paper kvs junior mathematics olympiad Regional Institute of Education(RIE) RTE Act SA1 sample papers Sample question paper class xii science Science Sample Papers Solution mathematics olympiad Spliup syllabus kvs class VIII summative assessment Summative Assessment 1 Sample Papers upsc x

BOOK FAIR

Dear Parent, Kendriya Vidyalaya No:2 is organizing Scholastic book fair in the School on 3rd, 4th and 5th August 2015 with a vision of “Putting a Book in every child’s hand. You are cordially invited to participate in the event whole heartedly. We believe that every student should be encouraged to become a lifelong reader.. Looking forward to your whole-hearted support. Venue: Library (1st floor) Timing: 8:30-3:00

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Twitter Updates

LIBRARY ON YOUTUBE

UBI ONLINE FEE COLLECTION

UBI ONLINE FEE COLLECTION

READER OF THE MONTH JUNE 2019

Book Exhibition Inauguration-2018

NIE Programme

Teachers Day 2017-Student Librarian

BOOK FAIR 2017

Book exhibition

Dr.K.Sreekumar along with readers' club members

BOOK TALK

Reader of the month July2017

Readers club programme

Shri:Mahipal Singh ,Principal

Work shop on newspaper in education :AUGUST2016

NIE workshop for primary section August 2016

BOOK FAIR

Scholastic Book fair August:2015

RSS Unknown Feed

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

Article Alert

1. R.Prasannan :Unfolding the Harappan mystery ,Page.58-60.The Week Vol.33. No.18 ,April.29,2012 2. VENKATESAN.V :Mission Impossible :Experts agree that the economic and environmental costs of interlinking India's rivers far outweigh its projected benefits., Frontline ,Volume 29 - Issue 07 :: Apr. 07-20, 2012

Magazine Alert

Magazine alert

Magazine Alert

MAGAZINE Alert

Terra Green

Magazine Alert

Magazine Alert

Down To Earth

Magazine Alert

Magazine Alert

Magazine Alert

Magazine Alert

Magazine Alert

RSS Competition Alerts

  • Tecxpo - 20 - Tech Innovations Project Competition & Quiz
    St. Mary's Institute of Technology & Science in connection with St. Mary's (Pvt.) ITI Silver Jubilee Celebrations organising Tecxpo -20 Technical Exhibition and Moto Show.The following competitions are being organised Inter College Project CompetitionWorking and still models related to automobile, civil, computer, electrical & electronics a […]
  • Competition for Logo Design of Kumbh Mela 2021
    The Government of Uttarakhand proposes to have a Logo for the Kumbh Mela- 2021 to be selected through open public competition. Accordingly, all Interested persons / parties(both Professional artists and Non-professionals) are hereby invited to participate in a Competition for design of the ‘Logo for Kumbh Mela-2021’. The last date for accepting entries is 25 […]
  • CBSE Reading Challenge 2019-2020
    As the goals, processes and assessment of learning move from memorization of information to acquisition of 21st century competencies of communication, critical and creative thinking and problem solving, the ability to locate, understand and reflect on various kinds of information has become more crucial. It is well accepted that Reading Literacy is not only […]
  • ZING Spellathon Championship 2020
    Zing Academy cordially invites to participate in  SPELLATHON 2020 – A grand spelling contest for the kids of classes LKG – Grade V. Venue: Anand Institute of Higher Education and Technology, Near Siruseri, OMR, Chennai. For details of the contest, please click on the link above and visit Scholastic World blog
  • Kids Painting Contest - Contester
    If you feel you have a photograph which suits the contest and not yet participated, what are you waiting for? Come, join by participating in this contest; It takes less than a minute to participate!  After participating, share your entry with your family and friends asking them to vote for you. You can easily share your entry on social media by using the soc […]
  • Children's Club Society Annual Inter-school Competitions
    Children's Club Society Announced the Annual Competitions 2020 Jan 25, 2020 – Story-Telling, Drama, Folk MusicJan 26, 2020 – Open Art CompetitionFeb 1, 2020 – Music (Junior) & RecitationFeb 2, 2020 – Music (Senior)Inter School & Open Competitions for School Children - 2020 [POSTER]Inter School & Open Competitions for School Children - 2020 [ […]

New Arrivals